Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Revolver

I bought this to replace the discontinued Urban Decay liquid eyeliner in Oil Slick (in the jar packaging).  This does stay on all day, but it is very glittery and a much lighter grey than Oil Slick.  They don't make it in a dark grey.  It is okay, just not a replacement for the color and packaging they discontinued.  As a side note, I opened this upside-down, and most of it spilled out...

Sephora Liquid Eyeliner in grey black

Okay, so I've been depressed ever since Urban Decay discontinued their liquid eyeliner in Oil Slick.  I have tried searching through major designer makeup brands to find a replacement in both color and applicator brush.  I am such a makeup snob.  This wonderful employee at the Sephora store asked if I had tried the Sephora brand.  What??!!  This is not EXACTLY the same, but a close match.  The color is perfect- I like a pewter/ dark grey for everyday use, and the applicator is still a brush, just not as soft as as the Urban Decay brand.  I found my replacement (for cheaper).

Urban Decay Liquid Eyeliner

This rocks!!!!  I buy it in Oil Slick, but there are other colors.  I love Urban Decay liquid liners.  This is the second package type this came in, and when I searched for it, it looks like they may have changed the packaging again.  It goes on smooth, and the control you have is optimal.  The end it soft, so you can really draw even lines. This is also dark grey, so it looks a little softer than black.  I will keep buying this as my go-to eyeliner. UPDATE: As far as I know, this has been discontinued....heartbroken